TRADE OFFER EVALUATIONS
TO
G Juuse Saros HYB (32) 87 8.5M UFA 2029 [1.5M retained this year]
TO
LW/RW Robby Fabbri 84 SNP (31) 4M UFA 2028
LW/C Blake Coleman TWF (35) 82 3M UFA 2028
RW/LW Maximilian Kunz SNP (18) 75 .800M RFA 2030
RATING (PASS/FAIL): PASS
EVALUATION: MTL needs a #1 goalie, and moving a couple older pieces to get a short term #1 goalie makes this worth it for MTL.
OFFER 2-A
Dinamo Riga GM To
RW Oliver Wahlstrom SNP 85 (27) 5.250M UFA 2030
LD K'Andre Miller TWD 86 (27) 6.000M UFA 2028 *DRG retains 3.000M
LW Leo Papitsa PLY 78 (18) .925M RFA 2030
DRG 2nd 2029
SOK 2nd 2029
to
LW Brandon Hagel PLY (29) 84 4.5M UFA 2028
LD Shea Theodore 90 TWD (32) 8M UFA 2028 (TOR retains 3M) Ice Pack
RATING (PASS/FAIL): FAIL
EVALUATION: Hagel and Wahlstrom are close to being a wash, however slight edge to Wahlstrom due to age and he would fit better than Hagel on MTL. Miller + Papitsa + 2 2nds is close fair value for Theodore, but MTL sees him as a top 2 pairing guy by himself, and although Miller is solid, they dont see him as someone that could replace Theodore’s production by himself. They would need more value coming back to part with Theodore.
OFFER 2-B
Macon Whoopee GM TO
C/RW Nicolas Roy PWF (30) 88 7.5M UFA 2031 Big Rig
LD Shea Theodore 90 TWD (32) 8M UFA 2028 (TOR retains 3M) Ice Pack
TO
C/LW Cole Sillinger SNP 87 (24) 7.5M RFA 2030 Make it Snappy, One Tee, Shnipe retain 3.5 retain 2028
LW Clarke Caswell PLY (21) 78 1.0M RFA 2029
LD Vladislav Gavrikov DFD (31) 86 4M UFA 2028
G Teodor Munther HYB (21) 78 1.1M RFA 2029
2030 1ST
RATING (PASS/FAIL): FAIL
EVALUATION: Sillinger - Roy is close in value for them, as it gives them a younger 1-2C, but it doesnt move the needle enough for Gavrikov + Munther + Caswell + 1st for Theodore. Gavrikov is a solid top 4 D but not someone that can carry a D pairing like Theodore, and with their blueline depth, they need either a high potential younger dman/prospect. They have a lot of forward depth, so Caswell would have a tough time making the roster. Munther is a good goalie prospect, but to move Theodore they would need a dman that could replace Theodores production (more OFD/TWD type).
OFFER 2-C
Iceland Crazy Vikings GM To
LD Sam Girard OFD 87 (29) 6.85M UFA 2028 NTC [PRG retains 3.425M]
PRG 2029 1st
PRG 2029 2nd
PRG 2030 2nd
To
LD Shea Theodore 90 TWD (32) 8M UFA 2028 (TOR retains 3M) Ice Pack
RATING (PASS/FAIL): PASS
EVALUATION: Girard still has 2 years left of upgrade eligibility and offensive production is close to Theodore’s. The first sweetens the deal a bit but they adding a good defensive prospect could make a better offer.
SHEA THEODORE RANKINGS:
1.
FAILED:
,
OFFER 3A
Detroit Rockers GM To
RD Jamie Drysdale OFD 85 (25) 6.5M RFA 2030
To
C Ryan Suzuki PLY 84 (26) 4.25M RFA 2029 Tape to Tape
RD Maxim Strbak TWD 83 (22) 2M RFA 2028
RW Carson Wetsch SNP 78 (21) 1M RFA 2029
RATING (PASS/FAIL): FAIL
EVALUATION: The offer is fair but the fit doesn’t work. Drysdale is their best under 27 dman, so moving him for Suzuki, who doesnt really fit into their top 9, just doesnt make sense for them to do. Strbak and Wetsch are okay pieces, but to consider moving Drysdale, itd likely need to be a lateral type deal where they can get a top 4 RD in return.
OFFER 4A
Detroit Rockers GM To
RW/LW Denis Gurianov 90 SNP (30) 9M UFA 2028 Snipe
To
LW/RW Pavel Dorofeyev SNP (26) 85 5M RFA 2028 Tape to Tape
LW/RW Nicolas Robertson SNP 85 (26) 6M UFA 2030
C Zakary Horvat-Edouard TWF (18) 72 .800M RFA 2030
LD Viljami Vuorinen DFD 75 (20) .800M RFA 2028 - FIN
RATING (PASS/FAIL): FAIL
EVALUATION: Gurianov has been a consistent 30 goal scorer, to move him they would need a 87+ younger winger with good potential to upgrade, and more. Doro and Robo are good middle 6 wingers but they already have a lot of 85 overall wingers.
OFFER 5A
Sokolina Hussars GM To
C Chaz Lucius PWF 84 (24) - 4.0M RFA 2028
C Alfred Persson PLY 67 (19) - 0.800M RFA 2029
LD Carson Lambos TWD 81 (24) - 1.75M RFA 2028
VAN 2028 1ST
KLA 2028 1ST
To
RW/C Jordan Kyrou PLY 89 (29) 9.5M UFA 2029 - MTL retains 1.75M. 7.75M hit
RATING (PASS/FAIL): FAIL
EVALUATION: Kyrou is currently their 1C, they would need a better piece coming back that could fill into their 1C spot, someone like Savoie + prospects/picks/another player. Lucius would not be able to fill in the 1C spot in the short term or long term. 2 1sts is not bad, but they are likely late round picks.